Tasty Pastry Shoppe – Brooklyn, NY: A Sweet Local Bakery Gem
Category:
Bakery / Pastry Shop
Introduction:
Tasty Pastry Shoppe in Brooklyn, New York is a popular neighborhood bakery known for its wide array of freshly made Italian-style pastries, cakes, cookies, and sweet treats that delight locals and visitors alike.
Why It’s Popular
This bakery stands out as a classic Brooklyn favorite thanks to its huge selection of desserts, traditional Italian pastries, and modern sweet creations. Locals love the freshness, variety and thoughtfully crafted sweets — from cream-filled pastries and cheesecakes to gluten-free or sugar-free options. The shop’s long history as a community staple and its reputation for quality makes it a go-to for birthdays, celebrations, or just a sweet craving.
What to Try
Here are some tempting must-try items at Tasty Pastry Shoppe:
- Cannoli & Lobster Tail Pastries — classic Italian favorites with rich cream.
- Cheesecakes (Strawberry, Red Velvet, Passion Fruit) — creamy, layered delights.
- Fruit & Berry Tarts — fresh and flavorful.
- Blackout Cake — decadent chocolate lover’s choice.
- Cookies & Breads — assorted cookies and freshly baked bread.
- Gluten-Free & Sugar-Free Treats — options for dietary needs.
Business Details
| Address | 8216-18 13th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11228, USA |
|---|---|
| Phone | (718) 833-9493 |
| Website | https://www.tastypastryshoppe.com/ |
| Opening Hours | |
| Tuesday–Saturday | 6:30 AM – 8:00 PM |
| Sunday | 6:30 AM – 5:00 PM |
| Monday | Closed (except holidays) |
Service Options
- Takeout / To-Go — fresh pastries and cakes available for pickup.
- Custom Cakes & Specialty Orders — custom celebration cakes and treats crafted on request.
Dining/Service Experience
Tasty Pastry Shoppe offers a classic bakery experience with a warm and vibrant display case packed with sweet options. The interior is more about browsing and choosing treats to go than seating; many customers prefer to take pastries home or enjoy them nearby. Friendly staff help guide selections, and the overall vibe reflects a beloved local bakery with nostalgic appeal and broad dessert variety.
Payment Methods
- Major credit/debit cards accepted (typically)
- Cash accepted (standard bakery practice — calling ahead to confirm is advised)
Customer Comments / Reviews
Here’s what people often say about this bakery:
“So many delicious desserts — cannolis, cheesecake and cookies were amazing!” — Local reviewer highlighting variety and quality.
“Fantastic selection of gluten-free and sugar-free options without compromising flavor.” — Guest comment on dietary-friendly treats.
“Busy but worth the visit — fresh, homemade goodies and classic Italian pastries.” — Frequent visitor insight.
Overall feedback emphasizes excellent variety, freshness, and friendly service, though the bakery can be popular and busy, especially around holidays.
Google Rating
Tasty Pastry Shoppe holds a strong ~4.7★ average rating from hundreds of online reviews — a sign of broad local admiration.
Google Map Location
Ending Section
If you’ve visited Tasty Pastry Shoppe or plan to try it, share your favorite dessert picks in the comments — and don’t forget to share this post with fellow sweet lovers who need a delicious stop in Brooklyn!