Tara Inn – Port Jefferson, NY: Classic Bar & Pub Comfort
Category:
Bar & Pub / Dive Bar & Eatery
Introduction:
Tara Inn in Port Jefferson, New York is a longtime local favorite bar and restaurant known for its classic pub food, cheap drinks, laid-back vibe, and community feel.
Why It’s Popular
Tara Inn has earned cult status over decades as one of Long Island’s most beloved local pubs and dive bars. With its incredibly affordable food and drink prices, old-school décor (including menu items written on paper plates on the walls), friendly bartenders, and a mix of locals and visitors, it’s become more than just a place to eat — it’s a community staple.
What to Try
Customers often rave about:
- $1 Burgers & $1 Roast Beef Sandwiches — legendary budget-friendly mains.
- Steak & Lobster Dinners — surprisingly well-flavored and hearty for the price.
- Local Beers & Drafts — ice cold, cheap, and perfect with pub grub.
- Chili & Comfort Sides — simple bar fare with good flavor.
- Pool Tables & Jukebox Fun — play games while you drink and eat.
Many reviewers note that the menu and prices have a nostalgic feel — dollar pricing for decades — though items like lobster and burgers can vary slightly over time.
Business Details
| Address | 1519 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777, USA |
|---|---|
| Phone | (631) 828-5987 |
| Website / Social | Facebook page (local info; no official website) |
| Opening Hours | Monday: 11 AM – 12 AM approx |
| Tuesday: 11 AM – 2 AM approx | |
| Wednesday: 11 AM – 3 AM approx | |
| Thursday: 11 AM – 3 AM approx | |
| Friday: 11 AM – 4 AM approx | |
| Saturday: 11 AM – 4 AM approx | |
| Sunday: 12 PM – 2 AM approx |
(Hours reflect the approximate times compiled from business listings and may vary seasonally or with special events.)
Service Options
- Dine-in / Bar Seating — casual, counter and table service.
- To-go / Takeout Available — many locals call ahead.
- Pool & Games — entertainment while you drink.
Dining/Service Experience
The experience at Tara Inn is authentic and unpretentious: wood-panelled walls, walls decorated with quirky menu notes, a full bar, pool tables, and sports on TV. It feels like a classic neighborhood pub where regulars know each other, and first-timers are welcomed like old friends. The atmosphere is loud, lively, and laid-back — not fine dining, but exactly right for casual eats and cheap drinks.
Payment Methods
Tara Inn typically operates with casual bar payment methods, and reviewers often note cash is commonly used, especially given the super low pricing on food; credit/debit acceptance can vary — check locally.
Customer Comments / Reviews
Here’s what visitors frequently share:
“Warm & welcoming, cheap eats, and a vibe you don’t get anywhere else — classic pub feels.” — Customer reflection (review summary)
“$1 burgers that actually taste great — affordable and tasty.” — Guest highlight (review summary)
“Great place to unwind with a cold beer, play some pool, and enjoy good company.” — Visitor review (review summary)
Locals also celebrate the community vibe — regulars, stories, friendly bartenders, and old-school bar charm that new bars often lack.
Google Rating
Tara Inn has around a 4.0★ average rating from reviews on Tripadvisor and local listings, making it well-loved as a casual dining and drinking spot.
Google Map Location
Ending Section
If you’ve ever dropped into Tara Inn or plan to visit, share your favorite menu finds or memories in the comments below — and don’t forget to share this post with friends who love classic neighborhood bars and unbeatable comfort food!