Experience Prime Steaks & Intimate Dining at Holstein Grill Steak House
1. Category
Steak House | Bar & Grill | Fine Dining Restaurant
2. Introduction
Hidden behind Ralph’s on Portion Road, Holstein Grill Steak House is Lake Ronkonkoma’s best-kept secret for premium steaks and intimate dining. This cozy gem combines exceptional food quality with warm hospitality, creating an unforgettable dining experience that rivals NYC’s finest steakhouses—without the Manhattan price tag or pretense.
3. Why It’s Popular
Holstein Grill Steak House has earned its exceptional reputation for numerous compelling reasons:
- Outstanding 4.9-Star Rating: With 346 reviews, this is one of the highest-rated steakhouses on Long Island
- Incredible Food Quality: Every dish is cooked to perfection with attention to detail that shows true culinary expertise
- Hidden Gem Status: Tucked away location creates an exclusive, intimate atmosphere that regulars treasure
- Signature Chimichurri: Their house-made chimichurri sauce is so good customers say “you could drink it”
- Warm, Attentive Service: Staff like Mimi (Miriam) and Rosie provide genuine, caring service that makes every guest feel special
- Perfect Date Night Spot: Cozy, quiet atmosphere with stunning interior that surprises first-time visitors
- Exceptional Value: Premium quality at reasonable prices ($50-100 per person)
- Fast Service: Food arrives hot, fresh, and beautifully plated without long waits
- Great Cocktail Selection: Handcrafted drinks including specialty martinis and creative concoctions
- Family-Owned Feel: The staff cares for the restaurant like it’s their own
- Stunning Interior: Don’t let the side entrance fool you—the inside is beautifully designed with great ambiance and lighting
- Fresh Ingredients: Everything from the bread to the vegetables receives the same high-quality attention
- Perfect Portions: Generous servings that satisfy without overwhelming
4. What to Try
Don’t miss these customer-favorite dishes at Holstein Grill Steak House:
Premium Steaks:
- Skirt Steak – Cooked to perfection, tender, flavorful, and paired with legendary chimichurri
- Filet Mignon – Butter-tender cuts cooked exactly to your specification
- Rib Eye Steak – Perfectly marbled and grilled to juicy perfection
Surf & Turf:
- Surf and Turf – Filet mignon paired with fresh lobster tail—a customer favorite
- Lobster Tail – Fresh, succulent, and beautifully prepared
Other Entrees:
- Grilled Pork Chops – Tender, juicy, and full of flavor
- Lemon Buttered Salmon – With roasted red potatoes
- Mixed Platter – A beautiful presentation with steak, chicken, pork chops, sausage, and lobster tail
Signature Sauces:
- Chimichurri – THE standout—bright, herby, garlicky, and absolutely incredible
- Salsa Verde – Fresh and flavorful bread accompaniment
Sides:
- Mashed Potatoes – Creamy and comforting
- Roasted Vegetables – So good even vegetable-haters ask for seconds
- Roasted Red Potatoes – Perfectly seasoned
Bread & Appetizers:
- Fresh Bread Basket – Warm, fresh bread that’s worth the visit alone
- With Chimichurri or Salsa Verde – Game-changing flavor combinations
Handcrafted Cocktails:
- Pornstar Martini – Expertly crafted by bartender Rosie
- Pineapple Lemonade – “Possibly the best drink ever” according to customers
- Homemade Arnold Palmer – With fresh lemon sour mix
- Sangria – Refreshing and perfectly balanced
Desserts:
- House-made Custard – Sweet ending to a perfect meal
💡 Pro Tip: Ask your server about off-menu specials—the chef is happy to create something unique for you!
5. Business Details
| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Address | 189 Portion Rd Unit B, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 11779 |
| Phone | (631) 285-3997 |
| Website | holsteingrillsteakhouse.com |
| Opening Hours | Monday – Thursday: 4 PM – 9 PM Friday: 4 PM – 10 PM Saturday: 3 PM – 10 PM Sunday: 3 PM – 9 PM |
| Price Range | $50-100 per person (Most guests report $30-50 to $50-100) |
| Reservations | Highly recommended (Accepts reservations) |
| Location Note | Located behind Ralph’s – same parking lot, side entrance |
6. Service Options
Holstein Grill Steak House offers flexible dining options to suit your needs:
✅ Dine-In – Full-service restaurant with attentive table service
✅ Outdoor Seating – Enjoy your meal al fresco (dogs welcome outside!)
✅ Takeout – Order ahead for pickup
✅ Delivery – Available for home delivery
✅ Catering – Perfect for special events and gatherings
7. Dining/Service Experience Options
Atmosphere: Casual yet elevated, cozy, quiet, and welcoming
Restaurant Style:
- Intimate, smaller space that creates a cozy, exclusive feel
- Stunning interior design with thoughtful lighting
- Clean, modern décor that surprises first-time visitors
- Awesome bar area for cocktails and socializing
- Side entrance location adds to the “hidden gem” experience
Service Format:
- Professional table service with genuine warmth
- Attentive staff without being intrusive
- Quick service—food arrives hot and beautifully plated
- Staff takes time to explain dishes and sauces
- Servers like Mimi (Miriam) and Rosie provide exceptional, personalized care
Accessibility Features:
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating throughout
Ideal For:
- Romantic date nights
- Special celebrations
- Family dinners
- Solo dining
- Group gatherings (advance notice recommended for larger groups)
- Intimate business dinners
Special Features:
- Bar onsite with craft cocktails
- Happy hour drinks available
- Late-night food options
- Vegan and vegetarian options available
- Kids’ menu and high chairs for families
Crowd:
- Family-friendly environment
- Perfect for groups
- Popular with locals who treasure this hidden spot
8. Payment Methods
Holstein Grill Steak House accepts all major payment options:
💳 Credit Cards – All major cards accepted
💳 Debit Cards – Accepted
📱 NFC Mobile Payments – Apple Pay, Google Pay, contactless payments
Parking:
- Free on-site parking lot
- Free street parking available
- Usually plenty of parking (shared with Ralph’s)
9. Customer Comments/Reviews
Here’s what delighted diners are saying about Holstein Grill Steak House:
Outstanding Reviews:
“I had an amazing experience at this restaurant. The skirt steak was cooked to perfection — tender, flavorful, and easily one of the best I’ve had. The lobster was just as impressive, fresh and delicious with every bite. My wife and I came here for date night, and it ended up being even better than we expected.” – Carlos Menoscal ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“The moment you walk in, you’re met with a comfortable, welcoming feel that sets the stage for a fantastic meal. Now, about that bread. It’s so good it might make you forget you came for steak. Add the chimichurri or the salsa verde and you’ve got a flavor combo that ranks among the best you’ll ever taste. I had the surf and turf — a perfectly cooked filet mignon paired with a delicious lobster tail. Everything on the plate was spot on.” – Joe Savino ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“10 stars all around. What a hidden gem. Throughout our whole time there [Mimi] was so sweet. She cares for the restaurant like it is her own. I ordered my favorite drink, the Pornstar Martini, which they do not have at many restaurants and Rosie made it amazing. We are so happy that we found this spot so close to us. Great food, great drinks and great service.” – Sara Mo ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“Wow we can’t say enough about our first time visiting. This little gem is right behind Ralph’s on portion road, same parking lot. Don’t let the side entrance fool you this place is stunning inside! Great ambiance, cute lighting awesome bar area. The food tho was out of this world. We were floored at how good every single thing was. The steak was prepared perfectly!” – Rachel Fredericks ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“1000/10!! A Hidden Gem That Deserves the Spotlight! The pineapple lemonade. I’m not exaggerating when I say it might be the best drink I’ve ever had. Surf and turf was cooked to perfection and full of flavor AND THE grilled pork chops were tender and juicy!!! And then there’s the chimichurri… wow. I don’t say this lightly- it was so good, you could honestly drink it. Bright, herby, garlicky, and packed with flavor.” – Elizabeth Altomare ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“We were extremely happy with our entire experience when we came for dinner. Friendly staff who were very attentive. They took the time to explain the different dishes and sauces that came with each and the chef cooked everything to perfection. Quiet atmosphere and fresh, hand crafted drinks. Perfect choice for dinner.” – Christine Becker ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“Dinner at Holstein Grill was an experience to remember. This place is a true hidden gem in Ronkonkoma. Our server, Miriam, was wonderful. Her service was genuine, attentive, and made the whole experience even better. We shared a beautifully presented platter that had a little bit of everything: steak, chicken, pork chops, sausage, and even a lobster tail. The chimichurri on the steak was a standout.” – N. Mitchell ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“Myriam was our server AMAZING service … I’ve been a server all my life so it was nice to be taken care of properly. We live down the street and found this place on google NEVER knew we had such a local hidden gem 5 stars… try 10 STARS. I’ve never seen my husband eat his vegetables so willingly or ask to eat mine… the chef really did his or her thing!” – Brianna LoBue ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Common Praise Themes:
- “Incredible food, intimate atmosphere, and quality that rivals the best”
- “Hidden gem” mentioned repeatedly
- Chimichurri sauce is legendary
- Perfect for date nights and special occasions
- Service is warm, genuine, and attentive
- Food arrives quickly and beautifully presented
- Clean, stunning interior surprises first-time visitors
- Reasonable prices for the exceptional quality
- Every dish cooked to perfection
Minor Note: The restaurant is on the smaller side, which can feel a bit tight during peak times. But customers unanimously agree the quality of food and service more than compensate for the intimate space.
10. Google Rating
⭐ 4.9 out of 5 stars (Based on 346 reviews)
Rating Breakdown:
- 5 Stars: 323 reviews (93.4%)
- 4 Stars: 12 reviews
- 3 Stars: 9 reviews
- 2 Stars: 1 review
- 1 Star: 1 review
This exceptional 4.9-star rating places Holstein Grill Steak House among the highest-rated restaurants in all of Long Island! An incredible 93% of customers give it five stars.
Price Distribution (Based on 214 customer reports):
- $50-100: 41.1% (Most Common)
- $30-50: 37.9%
- $20-30: 10.7%
- $100+: 8.4%
11. Google Map Location
📍 View Holstein Grill Steak House on Google Maps
GPS Coordinates: 40.8269807, -73.10566
Location Details:
- Address: 189 Portion Rd Unit B, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
- Located behind Ralph’s supermarket in the same parking lot
- Side entrance (don’t let this fool you—the interior is stunning!)
- Easy to find once you know where to look
Peak Hours:
- Busiest: Saturday 6 PM (prime dinner time)
- Moderate: Friday 7-8 PM, Thursday 6 PM
- Quietest: Monday-Wednesday evenings
- Typical Visit: 1-2.5 hours
Pro Tip: Make reservations for weekend dinners, especially Saturday evenings!
12. Ending Section
Ready to Discover Long Island’s Hidden Steakhouse Treasure?
Holstein Grill Steak House isn’t just another restaurant—it’s an experience that will make you wonder why you’ve been driving to Manhattan for great steaks. With its intimate atmosphere, legendary chimichurri, perfectly cooked meats, and service that makes you feel like family, this hidden gem behind Ralph’s has everything you’ve been searching for in a steakhouse.
🥩 Have you experienced the magic of Holstein Grill? Share your favorite dish in the comments below! Did you try the legendary chimichurri? What did you think of the surf and turf?
💬 Planning your first visit? Ask the community for recommendations! Fellow diners are eager to share their insider tips and must-try dishes.
📸 Spread the word about this hidden gem! Share this post with friends and family who love exceptional steaks and intimate dining. Let’s support this amazing local business!
🌟 Make Your Reservation:
- Call: (631) 285-3997
- Visit: holsteingrillsteakhouse.com
- Location: 189 Portion Rd Unit B (behind Ralph’s)
👉 Pro Tips for Your Visit:
- Make reservations, especially for weekends and date nights
- Ask for Mimi or Miriam for exceptional service
- Don’t skip the bread with chimichurri—it’s legendary
- Try the pineapple lemonade or Pornstar Martini
- Leave room for the vegetables (yes, really—they’re that good!)
- Arrive hungry—the portions are generous
- Visit Monday-Thursday for a quieter, more intimate experience
See you at Holstein Grill—where every meal is an occasion to remember! 🍽️